Antonio’s Pizzeria Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Antonio’s Pizzeria, where Italian comfort food meets a cozy family atmosphere in Westerville. This local gem specializes in handmade pizzas featuring their secret family sauce, complemented by fresh toppings that cater to every palate. The standout is their world-famous cheese pizza, renowned for its abundant cheese and homemade dough, made fresh daily.
Start your meal with mouthwatering homemade breadsticks or chicken wings, and don’t forget to pair your pizza with their delightful salads, like the Antipasto Salad loaded with savory meats and cheeses. Antonios’ vegetarian options ensure that everyone finds something to savor.
Whether you dine in their casual space or enjoy a meal on the patio, Antonio’s offers a perfect escape for lunch or dinner, making it ideal for families and groups. Don’t miss the inviting ambiance and friendly service that keeps customers returning time and time again!
Appetizers
Homemade Bread Sticks
taste what everyone is talking about! over 1 pound of mouth watering breadsticks covered with our garlic butter and parmesan cheese. served with our homemade ranch dressing or marinara sauce
Chicken Wings
a full dozen of plump juicy wings tossed in your choice of mild, medium, hot or bbq sauce. served with a side of homemade ranch or bleu cheese dressing
Boneless Chicken Wings
boneless all white meat tenders baked to perfection. tossed in your choice of mild, medium, hot, bbq or just plain. served with a side of homemade ranch or bleu cheese dressing
Garlic Bread
our fresh italian bread slathered with garlic butter and seasonings, baked to perfection
House Salad
crisp bed of lettuce with carrots and topped with provolone cheese and vine ripe tomatoes
Antipasto Salad
crisp bed of lettuce with carrots, provolone cheese, and vine ripe tomatoes, then covered with salami, ham, cheese, tomato, black olives and banana peppers
Grilled Chicken Salad
grilled chicken breast on a bed of lettuce with carrots, tomato, black olives and banana peppers
Salads
Our World-famous Pizzas
Handmade Pizzas - Cheese
our handmade pizzas start with our homemade dough made fresh everyday, and then topped with our secret family recipe sauce, loaded with a special aged provolone and whole milk mozzarella. create your own combination with our fresh toppings or choose one of our spectacular specialty pizzas. taste why antonio's pizza is becoming westerville's best selling pizza
Each Add'l Topping
Toppings available: Pepperoni, Mushroom, Onion, Homemade Sausage, Green Pepper, Green Olives, Black Olives, Banana Peppers, Jalapeños, Anchovies, Ham, Pineapple, Capicolla, Fresh Tomatoes, Bacon, Chicken.
Veggie Pizza
mushroom, onion, black olive, green pepper, banana pepper
All The Way
pepperoni, homemade sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper
Nonnas White Pizza
blend of ricotta, mozzarella and provolone cheeses, nonna's special seasonings and then topped with fresh tomato
Blt Pizza
this classic makes an unforgettable pizza. we prepare a special sauce, topped with a special blend of cheeses and lean bacon. covered with crisp lettuce, and ripe tomatoes
Ultimate Chicken
this irresistible combination of seasoned chicken and bacon and a blend of aged provolone and sharp cheddar cheeses finished with a touch of ranch dressing and vine ripe tomatoes. add jalapeños to spice up this tasty pie
Buffalo Chicken Chicken
we took our seasoned chicken and covered it with our savory buffalo sauce, then topped it off with a blend of aged provolone and sharp cheddar cheeses to create a delightful pizza
The Big Sammy
a huge portion of pepperoni, capicolla, ham, homemade sausage, and bacon. tempting for any meat lover
Fiesta Pizza
a blend of sharp cheddar and provolone cheeses. topped with sausage, onion, black olive, green peppers and fresh tomatoes
House Specialty Pizzas
Our Subs
Italian Sub
oven baked and piled high with salami, ham, capicolla, provolone cheese then topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, italian dressing, and banana peppers
Veggie Sub
oven baked with onion, black olive, green pepper, mushroom, banana pepper, provolone cheese then topped with lettuce, tomato and italian dressing
Pizza Sub
open faced sub with our pizza sauce, shredded provolone and sliced pepperoni
Meatball Sub
oven baked sub with our homemade meatballs, sauce and topped with provolone cheese
Sausage Sub
our very own homemade sausage patty topped with provolone cheese and oven baked, then topped with lettuce, onion, tomato, banana peppers and italian dressing
Chicken Parmesan Sub
tender all white chicken breast topped with marinara sauce and aged provolone cheese
The Classic
generous portions of our homemade sausage, pepperoni, banana peppers, and layered with aged provolone cheese
Three Cheese
loaded with ricotta, aged provolone, and whole milk mozzarella
The New Yorker
let this stromboli take you right to the big city! we combine pepperoni, ham, capicolla, aged provolone, and whole milk mozzarella cheese. this stromboli is big with taste
Create Your Own Stromboli
includes aged provolone cheese, then choose any of our fresh pizza toppings to create your own personal classic
Our Stromboli
Our Dinners
Chicken Parmagiana
fresh breast of chicken topped with provolone cheese and sauce. served with a side of spaghetti
Lasagna
ricotta cheese, seasoned ground beef and mozzarella cheese covering lasagna noodles and then topped with our homemade sauce
Spaghetti
a generous portion of our homemade spaghetti noodles along with a homemade meatball
Kids Spaghetti
served with a meatball (does not include salad or garlic bread)
Family Spaghetti
family portion of spaghetti, 4 meatballs, full order of gralic bread, and a family salad